EPLab Seminar Session

May 31, 2017

EPLab Seminar Session

"A crítica de Merleau-Ponty à noção de liberdade radical em Sartre/

Merleau-Ponty’s “Sartrean” critique of Sartre’s account of radical freedom"

- Luís de Sousa

Respondent: Ana Falcato

31 May | 16h-18h | Room 1.05, I&D Building

Abstract:

"We tend to associate Merleau-Ponty’s philosophical legacy with his insights into the nature of cognition and in particular into the role the lived body plays in it. For this reason, it may come as a surprise that Merleau-Ponty choses to close his Phenomenology of Perception with a discussion of the notion of freedom. In fact, Merleau-Ponty’s phenomenological analysis of perception has consequences that go well beyond the confines of the philosophy of mind and embodiment. In the Phenomenology of perception, Merleau-Ponty presents an account of subjectivity and human nature that, although terminologically similar to Sartre’s account in the Being and Nothingness at some points, radically challenges it. In my talk, I will discuss Merleau-Ponty’s views on freedom with a view to how they turn Sartre’s idea of the human being’s radical freedom on its head. I will bring into relief that, very much like Sartre, Merleau-Ponty links freedom to subjectivity, i.e., to the first-personal point of view, but, unlike Sartre, he does not view subjectivity as being in any way opposed to our factical condition as embodied, social and historical beings. On the contrary, for Merleau-Ponty, "facticity", i.e., embodiement, sociality, historicality, are a condition of freedom. It is true that it is possible to read Sartre’s position in this regard as being more ambiguous inasmuch as he contends that our “fundamental project” and our “situation” are essentially interrelated. Nevertheless, even in the face of this interdependence, Sartre maintained his idea of radical freedom. I will conclude by showing how Merleau-Ponty relies precisely on the Sartrian idea of the interdependence of the “fundamental project” and the “situation” to undermine Sartre's conception of absolute freedom."

Resumo:

"O legado filosófico de Merleau-Ponty tende a ser associado às suas ideias relativas à natureza da cognição, em particular no que diz respeito ao papel que o corpo vivido tem nela. Por esta razão, pode parecer surpreendente que A fenomenologia da percepção encerre precisamente com um capítulo dedicado à noção de liberdade. Na verdade, a análise fenomenológica da percepção tem consequências que vão muito para além do domínio da filosofia da mente e do corpo. Em A fenomenologia da percepção, Merleau-Ponty apresenta uma concepção da subjectividade e da natureza humana que, apesar de parecer terminologicamente semelhante, constitui uma crítica radical às concepções de O ser e o nada de Sartre. Na minha comunicação, pretendo precisamente mostrar que a concepção de liberdade de Merleau-Ponty pretende subverte a ideia sartriana de liberdade radical. Merleau-Ponty, tal como Sartre, associa a liberdade à subjectividade, i.e. ao ponto de vista da primeira pessoa. No entanto, não só a facticidade, isto é a nossa condição de seres encarnados, históricos e sociais, não se opõe, segundo Merleau-Ponty, à liberdade, como é, antes, uma condição dela. É verdade que a posição de Sartre a este respeito não deixa de se revestir de alguma ambiguidade na medida em que considera que o nosso “projecto fundamental” e a nossa “situação” são interdependentes. No entanto, apesar desta interdependência, Sartre mantém a ideia de liberdade absoluta. No final, vou mostrar que  Merleau-Ponty se baseia precisamente na ideia sartriana da interdependência entre o “projecto fundamental” e a “situação” para rejeitar a concepção sartriana de liberdade."

Back to previous page


Events

All Events

Wittgenstein and Applied Epistemology

Wittgenstein and Applied Epistemology - 6th Symposium of the International…

June 06, 2017

EPLab Seminar Session

"A crítica de Merleau-Ponty à noção de liberdade radical em…

May 31, 2017

Ethics and Meta-Ethics Reading Group

Ethics and Meta-Ethics Reading Group - 2017

April 19, 2017

"Moral Worth and Moral Motivation: Kant's Real View"

Paul Guyer's Conference

March 31, 2017

GOVERNMENT OF SELF, GOVERNMENT OF OTHERS

International Conference

March 06, 2017

EPLAB's Permanent Seminar – series 2016-2017

Moral-Epistemological Issues in von Wright

February 01, 2017

EPLAB's Permanent Seminar – series 2016-2017

'Kant: The Limiting Case of an Internal Reasons Theorist?'

December 07, 2016

Workshop CULT-COOP-01-2017: Democratic discourses and the rule of law

Workshop in preparation of a COST Action on Economic Governance…

October 27, 2016

"Formas de vida e práticas dos valores: políticas da subjectividade no último Foucault"

Ciclo de Seminários do EPLab

October 26, 2016

EPLab's Permanent Seminar

EPLab's Permanent Seminar - series 2016/2017

October 26, 2016

"Da acção à ética - Aproximação a uma teoria da acção na filosofia de J.-P. Sartre."

EPLab Conference

September 30, 2016

"Property-Owning Democracy and the Welfare State as Social Systems -Reconsidering Rawls's Critique of the Welfare State"

"Property-Owning Democracy and the Welfare State as Social Systems -Reconsidering…

September 22, 2016

"How Conflicts Makes (into) Law?"

EPLab Workshop - "How Conflicts Makes (into) Law?"

June 22, 2016

Intersubjectivity and Values: Phenomenological Perspectives

EPLAB INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE

June 14, 2016

Nietzsche & EP-Lab seminar session

"Liberal Democracy and Markets: An Evolutionary Political Theory of Preference…

March 16, 2016

EPLab Conference

EPLab Conference - Professor Vicente Sanfélix Vidarte

February 23, 2016

EPLab Conference - Jamie Buckland

EPLab Conference - Jamie Buckland

February 04, 2016

John Broome

EPLAB/ARGALB Joint Seminar on "Values and Human Action": John Broome

November 12, 2015

EPLab Conference - Alex Voorhoeve

EPLab Conference - Alex Voorhoeve

October 30, 2015

Conference - Philip Stratton-Lake

Philip Stratton-Lake to give a conference at IFILNOVA

October 16, 2015

Workshop with Jonathan Dancy

Jonathan Dancy on Moral Reasoning at IFILNOVA

May 22, 2015

Institutions

IFILNOVA
Faculdade de Direito Universidade Nova de Lisboa
FCSH
UNL
FCT